Within the context of American political radicalism in the latter half of the 20th Century, much attention has been focused on the struggle of Black America, and behind it, the revolutionary groups of the Long ‘68, such as the Weather Underground or the SLA, or the Young Lords or the Chicano Nationalist movement. Often forgotten in these discussions is the American Indian Movement and the wider Red Power struggle. These indigenous movements emerged during the revolutionary situation of the Long ‘68, amidst convulsions across indigenous society. Said convulsions reached their peak in the Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota at Wounded Knee, which became the site of a genuine national liberation war.
Though this national liberation war was a product of the wider political radicalism of the Long ‘68 within America, it also cannot primarily be understood as an episode in American revolutionary history. True, it happened within the borders of the U.S.; but the revolutionary uprising at Pine Ridge was a war against Euro-American society and its compradors on the reservation, and thus closer to a war of independence from America itself. It existed as a continuation of the so-called American-Indian Wars (albeit one also expressed as an attempted social revolution against the contradictions within reservation society) that popular historiography has often claimed came to an end with the massacre at Wounded Knee in 1890. Understanding it as such reflects the continuing state of colonialism that predominates reservation society and all indigenous nations within the U.S. today.
To start with, a brief overview of the immediate background of the uprising. In February 1973, South Dakota’s Pine Ridge reservation was in total political crisis. Unrest had flared within the context of the rising Red Power movement that had erupted across the continent in response to corruption, land loss, and poverty. This had provoked demands for the impeachment of the tribal chairman Dick Wilson. The tribal government’s response, reflecting its de facto status as a comprador force of American colonialism, called for support from the federal government, resulting in a federal invasion of the reservation, which in turn triggered an uprising at Wounded Knee. This rebellion, led by the radical indigenous grassroots organizations, the American Indian Movement (AIM) and the Oglala Sioux Civil Rights Organization (OSCRO), occupied the village for seventy-one days. Yet the uprising was not divorced from the international context of the Cold War. Wounded Knee was contemporary to the revolutions sweeping the Third World, and like them, was engaged in a revolutionary war for independence, being understood and treated as such by its own participants, enemies, and radicals from around the world.
Historiography of the uprising is broadly divided into two camps, what I term the legalist school[1] and the revolutionary school.[2] The legalist school includes perspectives both supportive and critical of the uprising, but interprets it as civil unrest born from political disputes within the reservation and within the confines of America’s political landscape. Meanwhile, the revolutionary school views the uprising as a form of indigenous resistance to colonialism, transcending the politics of local disputes, and focused on sovereignty and national liberation.
An example of this difference is as follows. Biolsi (see sources) argues that Wounded Knee was primarily about deposing the regime created by the Indian Reorganization Act (IRA) and not separation from America. The response of the revolutionary school would be that these two things are one and the same. The uprising can therefore be understood as a negation of the Euro-American settler state, demanding sovereignty and not civil rights.
The revolutionary school thus understands Wounded Knee not as part of the civil rights movement, but rather the Red Power movement. Per Blansett,[3] Red Power differs from civil rights in its commitment to separation from America. The uprising was not about changing the position of indigenous nations within the American settler-state, but about separating from America by taking the land back. This was in line with AIM’s wider political goals which, per Churchill, were viewed ‘not so much a matter of socioeconomic discrimination against Indians as it was their [colonisation] by the United States.’[4] For example, Dennis Banks (a founder of AIM) stated that indigenous nations must re-establish themselves as sovereign states,[5] while AIM’s chairman John Trudell argued indigenous grievances against the state and the white population must be viewed as grievances towards colonialism.[6] Thus, by 1973, AIM perceived itself as an anti-colonial movement, supporting the position of the revolutionary school.
However, there remain limitations within the revolutionary school. Even when interpreting Wounded Knee as an anti-colonial movement, it tends to be analyzed as part of the post-civil rights wave of American radicalism, placed in the same category of New Left militancy over identification with the Third World. Even attempts at internationalizing Wounded Knee, as done by Tóth in ‘From Wounded Knee to Checkpoint Charlie’ have focused on diplomatic ties between AIM and the Second World. Analysis of Wounded Knee as part of the Third World struggles of the period has thus been neglected.
Some Definitions
Before we can look at how Wounded Knee was part of the Third World, we must first establish some key terms. To start with, let's consider the meaning of the Long ‘68.
Per Vinen[7] the Long ’68 refers to those movements associated with 1968, but which ‘cannot be understood with exclusive reference to that year.’ The foundation of AIM in 1968 associates it with that year, but it reached its peak long after, fitting Vinen’s definition. Secondly, per Wallerstein, the revolutions of the world historical moment of ’68 all shared the themes of rejecting American hegemonic power and a skepticism towards the USSR as an accomplice to America’s world order.[8] Wounded Knee can be understood as fitting into this model. While it certainly rejected American hegemony, AIM did not defer to the Warsaw Pact. Though some connections and statements of support from both sides emerged, AIM was not a communist movement. Russel Means, a founder of AIM and key leader at Wounded Knee, rejected both capitalism and Marxism as ‘the same old song’ of industrial capitalism.[9] AIM (and therefore, Wounded Knee) thereby mirror Wallerstein’s argument, meaning these two international understandings of ’68 apply to Wounded Knee.
Secondly, to connect Wounded Knee to Third-Worldism, a definition of the Third World is in order.
Prakash and Adelman argue the Third World was defined by its commitment to international anti-colonialism, which sought alternative visions of a post-war world.[10]Prakash and Adelman’s view mirrors Wallerstein’s conception of ’68 in that it rejected both the First and Second Worlds. Wounded Knee, as will be shown later on, pursued just this type of post-war internationalist world-making which was against the First World and skeptical of the second. Internationalizing Wounded Knee thus becomes important for Third-Worldist literature as it brings Third-World internationalism into the territory of ‘First-World’ settler-states like the U.S., where coverage of Third-Worldism against settler-colonialism has often been neglected
Pine Ridge as Colony
In order to interpret Wounded Knee as a part of the anti-colonial revolutions of the Long ’68, it is necessary to determine if Pine Ridge functioned as a colony of America. Pine Ridge’s government was a creation of the 1934 ‘Indian Reorganisation Act’ (IRA) designed by John Collier, the 33rd Commissioner of the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Previously, reservations tended to be run as glorified prison-camps, led by agents who operated them as a direct colonial government.[11] However, under Collier’s auspices the IRA abandoned this approach in favor of a new form of colonial rule whose institutions were explicitly based on the practice of British indirect colonialism in the Pacific and Africa. Collier incorporated the ideas of British colonial officials into the IRA, writing that he considered the practice of indirect colonialism an art[12] and the only way to administer indigenous territory. Collier thus explicitly laid out the direct connection between the practice of colonialism within the British Empire’s holdings in Africa or the Pacific and the new constitutional order formed by the IRA. Of course, Collier, operating within the institutions of American liberalism, discussed the IRA in terms of democracy, but the aforementioned inspiration from British colonial models demonstrates that Collier’s vision was fundamentally a colonial one. Elections gave the running of day-to-day affairs to locals, but their institutions originated from Euro-American perspectives of liberal constitutionalism and continuing American dominance, and thus were subject to federal veto.[13] The IRA also cracked down on local political institutions within Pine Ridge as it rejected the fundamental unit of pre-colonial Oglala political life, the tiospaye, a system based on kinship networks[14] which had continued to hold authority in the reservations post-conquest.[15] Traditionalist supporters of pre-colonial politics criticized the IRA, arguing its constitutionalism was too rigid compared to Lakota political philosophy[16] and interpreted the IRA as eroding their sovereignty.[17] The political structure of Pine Ridge must therefore be seen as colonial in its imposition of a non-indigenous constitutionalism modeled on international colonial statecraft.
Parallels could be drawn between the idea of the systems of imperial internationalism that emerged following WW1 that defined the League of Nations. As has been argued by Maiolo and Robson,[18] the League of Nations (LoN) had achieved success not as a form of peace-addicted liberal internationalism, but as a source of imperial internationalism that sought to maintain and extend European imperial supremacy through the mandates and the denial of self-determination to other colonies.
This does not mean to say the IRA was a part of the LoN’s projects (though if the IRA had ever come into discussion among any people within the LoN is an interesting idea that merits investigation) but rather, just as Maiolo and Robson note, imperial internationalism was an important part of interwar diplomacy, and the connection between the IRA and British colonial practice reflects how America engaged in the ideas of imperial internationalism, if not through the League.
Pine Ridge’s political economy can also be compared to colonialism and the Third World. Post-IRA, the brunt of economic power was under the white population. By 1973, 80% of local industry and businesses were owned by whites and out-of-state companies, meaning profits left the reservation in a process Reinhardt describes as an ‘[economy typical] of a third world nation, focusing on attracting outside capital to develop natural resources’ while metropolitan centers sold manufactured goods to the reservation.[19] The IRA’s political economy precipitated endemic land loss on the reservation. By 1973, as much as 1,000,000 acres were operated by white ranchers, who cheaply rented the land from traditional landowners.[20]The economy of Pine Ridge was thus in the same camp of dependency the Third World occupied in the 20th Century. Pine Ridge must therefore be viewed not only as a neo-colony within America, but also forming parallels with the state systems of the Third World. Understanding Pine Ridge as such is necessary to frame the uprising at Wounded Knee as part of the revolutions of the Third World.
What was Wounded Knee?
Tensions in the reservation rose following Dick Wilson’s election as tribal chairman in 1972, after which he began to consolidate his power. The reservation’s ruling force was derived from the tribal council, which in 1973 was personified by the Wilson regime. Through the council’s control of funds, the chairman also controlled employment on the reservation, including the police. Utilizing systems of patronage, Wilson’s regime tied services and jobs to reservation authorities and the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) that[21] the 8,000-strong lumpen population of so-called ‘mixed-blood Indians’ relied on for employment.[22] The local white population, which populated the reservation’s south-east, was also fiercely supportive of Wilson’s regime, since Wilson formed political alliances with white landlords through land-leases.[23] By 1973, the government functioned as a comprador to colonialism. In response to rising discontent, the regime cultivated a police state through a paramilitary force nicknamed the GOONs (Guardians of the Oglala Nation) who would surveil, harass, beat, and even murder opponents of the regime.[24] Many of the GOONs came from the aforementioned lumpen population of so-called ‘mixed-bloods’ who depended on the tribal council for employment.[25] GOONs would come to make up one-third of the BIA police force[26] and received funding and support from white ranchers and settlers.[27] The settler population’s influence was so rampant that AIM leader Russell Means presented the reservation as essentially a settler-dictatorship, where the whites formed a coalition with the federal government to terrorize the local population.[28]
Thus, the same principles of patronage networks and clientelism that govern regimes in the Middle East and the Third World more broadly also existed at home among the semi-colony of Pine Ridge.
Increasing corruption, GOON repression, and land loss prompted protests against Wilson, calling for his impeachment as the tribal council was increasingly seen as a puppet-state of America, dominated by ‘mixed-blood elites.’[29] In an attempt to rally federal support, Wilson called on the federal government to come to the reservation to keep AIM out (AIM was protesting in the area after the murders of a number of indigenous people).[30] The Wilson regime was openly against AIM and supported federal-level efforts to outlaw it.[31] In one press release, Wilson even called for all AIM members to be killed.[32] Subsequently, on 11 February, 65 U.S. Marshals and more FBI agents occupied the reservation.[33] The occupation banned all public meetings and protests and fortified the BIA building with sandbags and machine guns, earning it the nickname ‘Fort Wilson.’[34] The occupation was heavy-handed even by Wilson’s standards, who recounted that the federal occupation ran the reservation as a ‘police state.’[35]
The outrage on Pine Ridge was immediate and saw the creation of the Oglala Sioux Civil Rights Organization (OSCRO), which, despite the invasion, pushed for impeachment proceedings to continue. These proceedings (over which Wilson presided) ‘surprisingly’ failed to impeach him.[36] Hundreds of OSCRO members and their supporters marched on ‘Fort Wilson’ in protest. Meeting at Calico Hall, they planned how to overthrow Wilson,[37] forming a de facto system of dual power within the town. The Calico Hall government could therefore be said to have functioned similarly to organizations such as the popular resistance committees that emerged in other Third-World revolutions, such as the 8888 Uprising of Burma, or the Sudanese revolution of 2019.
On February 25, the FBI invaded Calico Hall, prompting the traditionalist population to call upon AIM to come to the reservation and help fight. When AIM entered, they occupied Wounded Knee, since a frontal assault on ‘Fort Wilson’ would be suicidal. AIM itself never sought to position itself as the instigator at Wounded Knee, pointing out in a statement that it was assisting the takeover, but the occupation was begun by traditional leaders.[38] The occupation thus began with the formation of an alliance between AIM, which came from the urban radicalism of the ’68 generation, OSCRO, and the traditionalist population who supported a return to pre-colonial government.[39]
Local Perceptions of Wounded Knee
Throughout the occupation, the rhetoric, goals, and actions employed by AIM and OSCRO repeatedly mapped onto the lines of Third-World internationalism expressed through three vectors. First was a connection of Wounded Knee to Third-World struggles, especially Vietnam. Vietnam was constantly compared to the struggle at Pine Ridge, and in doing so AIM presented an understanding of Wounded Knee as a national-liberation war of the Third World within the U.S. The second vector was AIM’s emphasis on the 1868 Treaty of Fort Laramie. Deferral to the treaty, which recognized the Lakota as a sovereign state,[40] manifested as a rediscovery of Fort Laramie in a ’68 context, allowing AIM/OSCRO to adopt the language of Third-Worldist national liberation. The third vector was AIM’s approach to the United Nations. AIM sought to present its demands through the UN in a bid for international recognition in a process that paralleled the Third-World’s relationship with the UN. Taken together, these three factors illustrate an understanding of Wounded Knee by its participants as a campaign of national liberation from the American nation itself, identifying this struggle with international revolutions and the politics of the Third World.
Vietnam and the Third World
Throughout Wounded Knee, its participants connected their struggle to global Third-World anti-colonial revolutions. Primarily, these comparisons were drawn with Vietnam, but were also placed into the political terrain of the Third World more broadly. In a leaflet from 1974, AIM presented Wounded Knee as a source of guidance for Third-World movements, arguing they represented the only true revolutionary group in America because they were the only ones acting as a sovereign people with an established land base.[41] This publication demonstrates a connection by AIM of itself to the Third World, and through its reference to an indigenous land-base, invokes the terms of national liberation. Identification with the Third World was reinforced in December 1973 when Dennis Banks (a co-founder of AIM and Wounded Knee veteran) called for Arab states to support indigenous militancy for plans for an attack on oil pipelines in Alaska.[42] In this period, Arab states such as Libya or Algeria were important participants of Third-Worldism, offering support to Third-World movements around the world. AIM’s appeal to them reflects that they saw themselves as compatible with these internationalist Third-Worldist networks.
However, while these statements are notable, Vietnam is what AIM constantly deferred to during and after Wounded Knee to identify with the Third World. Activists involved with Wounded Knee referred to their struggle and other acts of indigenous militancy as a series of ‘mini-Vietnams’[43], equivocating Wounded Knee to the Vietnam War. At Wounded Knee, one AIM fighter concluded ‘We have learned from the Vietnamese. They have fought for their independence for generations, and now we will do the same.’[44] Traditionalists at Pine Ridge also evaluated Wounded Knee in this way. One named Guy Dull Knife Jr., a Vietnam veteran, commented the Oglala ‘had become the [Viet-Cong] in our own homeland.’[45] Awareness over parallels between Vietnam and the Oglala had already existed beforehand among indigenous Vietnam veterans. Reflecting on his time in the war, Dull Knife said he ‘often wondered if what we were doing to the Vietnamese wasn’t the same as what the army had done to us.’[46] Medical workers at Wounded Knee echoed this sentiment, comparing the experience of the uprising to their work in Vietnam.[47] This sentiment was also popular among regular citizens at Wounded Knee, who compared the actions of the federal forces to fighting in Vietnam.[48] Indigenous media also commented on these similarities, with one cartoon from the newspaper Wassaja in their 1 May 1973 issue comparing American actions at Pine Ridge to Vietnam, depicting a man confusing bombing-raids in Indochina with attacks on the Dakotas.
Therefore, throughout all segments of Wounded Knee and indigenous society, a sense of solidarity and connection emerged between them and the Vietnamese.
One important source in detailing these internationalist feelings comes from a collection of statements and interviews of Wounded Knee veterans collected by the Akwesane Notes. The collection reflects a highly internationalist understanding of Wounded Knee, showing that these comparisons did not stop at criticisms of American actions but included the wider context of Pine Ridge’s political economy. American support to the Wilson regime was compared by Dennis Banks to being analogous to American support for South Vietnam.[49] While Ken Tilsen, a lawyer for AIM, compared the tribal council to South Vietnam’s government, framing Wilson as a Thiệu-like figure: Corrupt, backed by America, and repressing the people for personal gain.[50] If the Wilson regime was being compared to the Thiệu government of South Vietnam, the obvious implication was that AIM-OSCRO was analogous to the Viet-Cong.
Others put this comparison in more direct terms. Vietnam veteran Woody Kipp would remark that while he was at Wounded Knee he had come to realize that the citizens of Pine Ridge had become Viet-Cong.[51] So much so that Kipp titled his autobiography ‘Viet-Cong at Wounded Knee.’ This was a common position among veterans at the occupation, one recounting both events as being ultimately the same. He argued the wars in Korea, Vietnam, and Wounded Knee were all part of the same broader trend of white aggression against the non-white world.[52] They compared themselves to Viet-Cong, arguing that they too were fighting for their land, and equated their stand at Wounded Knee to Dien-Bien-Phu and Khe-Sanh.[53] Another compared Wilson to ‘[the US] puppet, Thiệu’ remarking Wounded Knee was the same type of war as Vietnam.[54] Identification with Indochina became so strong that even the supply routes going in and out of the village were dubbed the ‘Ho Chi Minh Trail.’[55] The no-man’s-land that formed between the village and the FBI, as illustrated below, was termed the DMZ by AIM, which Dennis Banks explained was a reference to the DMZ in Vietnam.[56] The news of the occupation had a similar effect on indigenous soldiers already deployed to Vietnam, who in phone calls to Wounded Knee stated they realized they had no business there, and wished they could fight at Wounded Knee instead.[57] Wounded Knee thus not only reflected solidarity with Vietnam, but also connected the politics of Pine Ridge to global patterns of imperialism in the Third World.
Furthermore, present in the occupation’s rhetoric was a constant deference to the Third-Worldist language of national-liberation, often compared to Vietnam. This was put into practice on March 8, as AIM-OSCRO declared the creation of the Independent Oglala Nation (ION) provisional government at Wounded Knee. The ION was to be structured on traditionalist grounds, by returning to the political institutions of the pre-colonial era as established in the 1868 treaty of Fort Laramie[58] but was also connected to the politics of the Third World. For example, one pamphlet issued by AIM described the ION as equivalent to the Provisional Revolutionary Government of South Vietnam,[59] the rival government to South Vietnam created by Vietnamese guerrillas. The comparison was implicitly repeated in 1976 when Ed Bernstick (the director of AIM’s Canadian branch) met with the PGRSV after their victory to celebrate what AIM viewed as ‘their common victory over imperialism and [America.]’[60] This reflects an understanding by AIM of their goals at Wounded Knee and elsewhere as the same as other Third-World revolutionaries. The prevailing rhetoric within the ION reflects what Prakash and Adelman consider a defining aspect of the Cold War’s Third World, an identity derived from internationalist anti-colonialism.[61] AIM’s statements and the attitudes of Wounded Knee’s participants reflect support for and identification with Third-World states, especially Vietnam. They thereby illustrate that Wounded Knee must be seen as part of the Third World within the Long ‘68.
Fort Laramie
The language of the occupation was explicitly connected to decolonization through the treaty of Fort Laramie, which constantly haunted the occupation. The treaty was always invoked to either explain AIM/OSCRO’s goals or to justify the uprising, such as when Means argued the occupation was justified as the federal occupation of Pine Ridge ‘[violated] our rights as established in the 1868 treaty.’[62] Fort Laramie ceded to the Lakota all areas west of the Missouri River within South Dakota and forbade the territory’s settlement.[63] In a press statement, Means explained that AIM had come to Wounded Knee because all the areas delineated by Fort Laramie belonged to the Lakota, not America.[64] Within AIM’s perspective, Fort Laramie formed the borders of a national land base under foreign occupation. By invoking it, AIM suggested its goal was national liberation of a territory that included all of Western South Dakota.
In AIM’s rhetoric, 1868 was synonymous with the model of indigenous governance that existed before the modern reservations. One AIM supporter stated the tribal government was foreign, with the only alternative being a return to the institutions of 1868.[65] What a return to 1868 would signify, alongside the reinstallation of traditional Oglala institutions, was complete sovereignty from America.[66] For instance, following the ION’s creation, Means issued a statement rejecting Oglala citizenship within America, asserting their establishment of Wounded Knee as sovereign land.[67] While in a later interview, he would explain that AIM intended for the U.S. government to start dealing with Pine Ridge on the same basis it would deal with countries like Sweden or Nigeria.[68] Government negotiators were told the ION was operating under the provision of Fort Laramie against an act of war by America.[69] AIM considered themselves not to be protesting America, but rather at war so as to enforce Fort Laramie’s provisions. In doing so, AIM directly placed Wounded Knee in the historical terrain of anti-colonialism. The ION was recognized by indigenous reporting as a ‘latter-day equivalent of the Great Sioux Nation.’[70] Traditionalist figures like Frank Fools Crow affirmed this sentiment, framing the federal government as trespassers on the land of the Oglala who must be removed[71] through ‘a resumption of action’ in a war that had started in 1890 at Wounded Knee.[72] This sentiment remained popular in Pine Ridge, with one flag made by anti-Wilson guerrillas reading ‘THE INDIAN WARS ARE NOT OVER’ (see below). The centrality of armed struggle was emphasized through presenting Leonard Peltier, an AIM fighter arrested by the FBI, as a prisoner-of-war of the BIA, as shown by the ‘POW-BIA’ patch, a parody of the POW-MIA flag for American casualties in Vietnam. A figure holding a rifle over the caption Lakota Nation can also be seen, further stressing the emphasis on armed struggle to achieve national liberation for the Lakota. This flag reflects a perception of Pine Ridge as a site of an active national-liberation war, continuous with the pre-colonial wars against America, yet rediscovered through the language of ’68 by invoking the language and symbols of national-liberation.
The civilian population also agreed. Two citizens of Wounded Knee recounted the ION, saying it was a nation they were fighting to liberate.[73] While AIM’s supporters at Pine Ridge picketed ‘Fort Wilson’ with the slogan ‘Yankee go home!’[74], presenting the federal occupation as a foreign force, whilst borrowing slogans that were popular in the Third World. In presenting the ION as a nation to be freed, the language of Third-World national liberation dominated discourse on the ION.
Finally, the ION’s governance created a synthesis between 1868 and the political culture of 1968. The ION’s declaration emphasized their intentions of making a ‘corporate-state’ that would envelop Pine Ridge and oust the IRA regime.[75] Accounts from Akwesane Notes demonstrate the ION took on the responsibilities of a revolutionary-state, forming administrative committees on housing, medical care, immigration, internal security, information, and defense,[76] while democratic-councils gathered people to discuss military-political matters,[77] no doubt based on the experience of OSCRO in the immediate days and weeks before the revolt. Within the ION, the politics of traditionalism was combined with the practice of the democratic-revolutionary politics of ’68.
Finally, it is also worth adding that the goals of AIM at Wounded Knee surpassed those of just Pine Ridge. I have written about this topic before, so I will avoid repeating myself too much. But to summarise, AIM saw Pine Ridge as the first step in a continental plan for revolution. The state system of Pine Ridge would be brought crashing down, and from there revolution would spread, either by hook or by crook, to reservations throughout America, and eventually, the whole Western Hemisphere.
Overall, these facts reflect a rediscovery of Fort Laramie in the context of ’68. The ION’s presentation as a return to pre-colonial politics connected Wounded Knee to both the Long ’68 and the Third World. In seeking to resurrect pre-colonial government, the ION reflects Wallerstein’s conception of ’68 as rejecting both American and Soviet political norms alongside Prakash and Adelman’s conception of the Third World as ‘a construct to create a different historiography and narrative consciousness’ by forming non-European political structures.[78] This was combined with the revolutionary politics of ’68 and Third-Worldist internationalism, which also connect to Prakash and Adelman’s conception of Third-World politics and world making. The utilization of Fort Laramie thereby existed as a rediscovery of the treaty in the context of Third-Worldism and the Long ’68.
The United Nations
Following decolonization, post-colonial states began to form a majority of countries on Earth and the UN’s General Assembly. In this climate, the Third World began to understand the UN as a platform for their own agendas.[79] India’s Nehru, for instance, saw the UN as a tool to achieve planetary justice for the Third World[80] while Burma’s U Nu argued the UN needed the Third World to function.[81] Wounded Knee was not left out of the turn to the UN. During the siege, the ION met with the UN to request admission as a member state, attempting to use post-war internationalist institutions the same way as the rest of the Third World.
An appeal to the UN was greenlit by traditionalist leaders who saw Wounded Knee as their only chance to regain sovereignty.[82] This delegation included representatives from the ION and the Iroquois Confederacy[83] holding a series of meetings with UN officials calling for the recognition of the ION’s independence. AIM official Vernon Bellecourt argued that America’s treaties with indigenous nations were between sovereign states. Though the U.S. ignored its obligations, indigenous nations still considered themselves independent.[84] Bellecourt sought to bring this perspective to the UN Security Council, and to pursue UN membership for the ION.[85] This mission was framed in internationalist terms, as one spokesman explained the ION’s recognition was a matter of international law since these treaties were signed between sovereign states.[86] These demands received mixed recognition from the UN. Under-Secretary-General Constantin Stavropoulos did not recognize the ION’s claims, considering Wounded Knee within American domestic jurisdiction, and directed them to the Human Rights Committee.[87] Conversely, in a separate meeting with Under-Secretary-General Narasimhan, they were deferred to both the Human Rights Committee and the Special Committee on Decolonization.[88] Deference to the SCD is notable as it denotes a subtle recognition by some of those at the UN that colonialism may be a factor at Wounded Knee. The SCD was established as a committee to oversee the elimination of colonialism in what it terms Non-Self-Governing Territories (NSGTs).[89] The ION never achieved this designation, nor did they seem to pursue it, but this suggestion by UN officials, if followed, could have placed Wounded Knee in the same ranks as NSGTs like Namibia or East Timor.[90]
In a separate meeting with Narasimhan, Bellecourt referred to the events at Wounded Knee as a popular revolution, which, having no allies, turned to the UN for recognition as sovereign states.[91] Reflecting the ION’s commitment to internationalism, the principle of indigenous sovereignty was noted in their statements to extend to Canada, Mexico, and Latin America. They called for the UN to send delegations both to Pine Ridge and to indigenous communities in Latin America to prevent genocide. In discussing what this sovereignty would mean, the delegation recognized that most indigenous nations were territorially surrounded and thus invoked the 17th Century Two-Row Wampum Treaty as a model of sovereignty within the framework of parallel government over the same territory where the ION and America would be separate but equal. Narasimhan stated UN bureaucracy prevented him from granting anything without a UN sponsor. Bellecourt responded that they had goals to pursue sponsorship from a member-state to introduce a resolution to the UNSC and General Assembly, though no plan was specified.[92] The closest Narasimhan came to offering the ION a platform was to use the Human Rights Commission to give a comment to the USA.[93]
Overall, the UN’s response was to brush off the delegation, even if a slight deferral to the SCD reflects a fleeting recognition of a colonial factor at play. Regardless, the ION’s delegation to the UN reflects an engagement with internationalist institutions to present their case through the same avenues other Third-Worldists used after decolonization, mirroring the rhetoric of Third-World approaches to the UN. Even if they were not recognized, the ION nevertheless acted like a Third-Worldist state in attempting to use the UN for decolonization. Secondly, the ION also reflected an internationalist understanding of Third-Worldism by additionally calling for UN missions to Third-World indigenous nations. In connecting their appeal to anti-colonial programs in Latin America, yet another link arises with Wounded Knee and Prakash and Adelman’s conception of the Third World as dependent on internationalist anti-colonialism. Together, these factors reflect an understanding of Wounded Knee linked to the internationalism of the Third-World’s Long ‘68.
Wounded Knee and its Discontents
However, if we are to argue that Wounded Knee was a force identical to Third-World national liberation, it begs the question. Would America and America’s allies not treat it as such? As it will now be shown, that is precisely what occurred.
Enemies of Wounded Knee included the reservation’s government, the federal government, and America’s conservative press, all of which viewed Wounded Knee as part of the wider anti-colonial revolutions of the Long ’68. Rhetorically, they interpreted it as a new front in the Cold War, connected to international communism and Third-Worldism. In practice, they acted accordingly through the comprador regime’s enactment of violent repression with federal support post-occupation. This repressive campaign followed similar patterns of US-backed repression against revolutionaries in the Third World, demonstrating that the enemies of Wounded Knee saw the uprising as part of the Third World’s Long ’68.
The Tribal Government
The arguments used to frame Wounded Knee by its enemies paralleled the arguments used to understand and analyze Third-World revolutionary struggles in the Cold War. Doing so was a central policy of the tribal government to rhetorically counter the occupation. Dick Wilson, for example, cited Domino Theory in relation to Wounded Knee, arguing that the government victory at Wounded Knee ‘strengthened tribal governments… nationwide’ and that a victory for AIM would have ‘been like dominoes’ for the rest of the reservations that used the IRA system.[94] It could be argued that this was just grandstanding on Wilson’s part; however, not only was this AIM’s long-term plan, but unrest had already sprung up across different reservations in reaction to Wounded Knee. At any rate, regardless of whether it was grandstanding or not, Wilson surely knew what he was doing when he invoked the terminology of domino theory.
Wilson noted that other reservation governments were also concerned over the spread of revolution, and that for a time, they did not vocally support his regime for fear of sparking attacks in their own territory.[95] The usage of domino theory was further connected to the language of the Cold War, as Wilson dubbed the traditional indigenous politics of the tiospaye that Wounded Knee sought to return to power, a communist ideal.[96] This also reveals an identification of the reservations with the Third World. Per Westad, domino theory emerged as a way to subsume under communism any resistance to capitalist pro-US Third-World states.[97] Its invocation at Wounded Knee not only points to an international understanding of the uprising in terms of Cold War politics, but also implicit identification of Wounded Knee with Third-World revolution. In doing so, Wilson presented his regime at Pine Ridge as a shield of reaction to indigenous revolution, where, if AIM was defeated, it would prevent the spread of Red Power revolution elsewhere. Pine Ridge’s government all of a sudden occupied the same role for the “Red Nations” of America that Israel does for the Middle East, or Apartheid South Africa for Africa’s southern cone.
Domino theory also influenced tribal rhetoric in the prelude to the occupation. During his impeachment hearings, Wilson showed a John Birch Society (JBS) movie called ‘Anarchy U.S.A.’[98] which presented the civil-rights movement as the next ‘domino’ of communist world-revolution. Interspersed with footage from the Cuban, Algerian, and Chinese revolutions, it argued civil rights was following their path for a global communist conspiracy to enslave mankind.[99] The obvious implication was that Wilson’s dissenters were communist puppets, and followed the path of revolutions in China, Algeria, and Cuba. Wilson would reiterate this view, accusing AIM of being a ‘communist-front organization.’[100] In talks with the press, he alleged that AIM visited Hanoi, received funds from the USSR and China, and reiterated that Pine Ridge authorities were a shield of reaction against AIM’s international conspiracy.[101]
Thus, one of the principal enemies of Wounded Knee, the Wilson regime, ultimately interpreted the occupation in the logic of the Cold War, connecting it to patterns of Third-World revolution, borrowing the logic of domino theory and alleging that Wounded Knee was the latest offensive in a global communist conspiracy. In this way, Wounded Knee was connected to the international ’68 in the Third World.
The Federal View
Statements from across the Federal government over Wounded Knee illustrate how it appraised the uprising as part of the Third World. In 1976, the US Congress held an investigative report into AIM led by senator and plantation owner James Eastland. The summary of the report concluded that AIM was a revolutionary organization, tied to Cuba, with some of its leaders being Marxist-Leninists.[102] The alleged connection with Cuba and Marxism-Leninism connected AIM and Wounded Knee to the radical movements of the Third World and the Cold War, of which Cuba was an important sponsor. It further claimed that AIM had ties to a wide variety of Third-World radicals and their allies, including China, the Irish Republican Army, and the Palestinian Liberation Organization.[103] These ties were not necessarily completely fabricated. Means, in his autobiography, commented that AIM did have friendly ties with the PLO, for example, which allowed them to travel to Iran during the Islamic revolution.[104] Cold War suspicions were inserted into the report, with the commission pointing to the presence of the Soviet newsagent Iona Andronov at Wounded Knee and their support for AIM as at least proof of Soviet diplomatic support for the uprising, described as ‘disturbing Soviet propaganda’[105] (What the propaganda was supposed to be exactly, remains a mystery). While in the report’s discussion on AIM’s global connections, it placed AIM into an international Third-World network consisting of the PLO, IRA, Iranian Student Associations, and various Puerto Rican radical groups.[106]
The writings of Joseph Trimbach on Wounded Knee also reflect how the federal government saw Wounded Knee in this light. Trimbach is of importance because he was the FBI’s Special Agent in Charge at Pine Ridge and oversaw FBI operations in the first weeks of the revolt. Though initially his conception of Wounded Knee was that it was a staged revolt,[107] this had later changed to the label of a war.[108] One he would identify as America’s ‘longest [domestic] armed conflict since the Civil War.’[109]
For Trimbach, this war had strong parallels with Vietnam. Commenting on AIM’s defensive fortifications he stated they were ‘arranged in a manner very similar to Viet-Cong field fortifications…’[110] Mirroring Wilson’s usage of domino theory, Trimbach worried an indigenous victory would pave the way for similar uprisings across the country,[111] the same logic used to justify American intervention in Indochina. However, AIM was not the only target of these comparisons. Trimbach also criticised the federal strategy for following the same patterns of anti-insurgent warfare at Vietnam, writing ‘in order to “save the village” the government had to let it be destroyed, house by house.’[112] Trimbach was not alone in the FBI in comparing Wounded Knee to imperialism elsewhere. The FBI’s Special Agent in Charge at Rapid City described their role at Pine Ridge as ‘a colonial police force’[113] further comparing Wounded Knee to the Third-World. The course of Wounded Knee, in the view of federal forces at the siege, was therefore identified within the broader trends of Third-World revolution in the Cold War.
However, Trimbach also went a step further. Trimbach wrote his account in the years after 9/11, and in this context compared the government’s campaign against AIM to the War on Terror. Though Trimbach does admit that AIM presented a much smaller threat than forces like al-Qaeda, he nevertheless argued that ‘the “war” against AIM [had] parallels to today’s war against terror’ and that ‘The occupation of Wounded Knee can be viewed as a microcosm of today’s terrorist controversies.’[114] Wounded Knee thus became a smaller scale Fallujah, Mogadishu, Kandahar, or Gaza. Trimbach presented AIM as having ‘the same viciousness [as] Middle-Eastern henchmen [who] lop off the heads of innocent people’ and further noted that they ‘employ[ed] many of the same tactics used by modern-day terrorist groups’[115] even going so far as to refer to Wounded Knee as AIM’s ‘jihad’[116] thereby drawing parallels between AIM and organisations like al-Qaeda and Hezbollah. Trimbach finished the analogy by citing the trial of al-Qaeda member Richard Reid, concluding that statements made by Reid’s judge applied to AIM-guerrillas like Leonard Peltier.[117]
Trimbach’s comparisons matter, as they demonstrate a fundamental perception of Wounded Knee as one with the broader Third World. Though American attacks on the Third World in the 20th century were defined by the Cold War, once it ended, the Global War on Terror (GWOT) took its place. Trimbach’s connection of AIM transitioning from Cold War analogies to al-Qaeda or Hezbollah reflects an identification of Wounded Knee as fundamentally outside the confines of American politics, and above all with the Third World. That it could then be compared to the shape of Third-World resistance in the 21st Century reflects a certain ‘staying power’ of Wounded Knee in the federal imagination as a type of ‘Third-World’ at home. Throughout federal perceptions, Wounded Knee was therefore identified with the Third World, in both a Cold War and post-Cold War context.
Conservative Reaction at Wounded Knee
During the occupation, the ION utilized imagery and the power of symbols to connect themselves to struggles in the Third World. This was a connection that conservative opponents of Wounded Knee picked up on. For example, an AK-47 brought by an indigenous Vietnam veteran was photographed in the hands of one ION soldier (see below). The imagery of the AK-47 was emphasized by the ION and quickly ‘appeared on the front page of nearly every newspaper in the country.’[118] Even the congressional report noted the weapon’s presence.[119] The obvious implication of focusing photoshoots on the AK-47 (a weapon which had become the icon of Third-World revolution)[120] was to link the Wounded Knee to Third-Worldism. Here, the ION succeeded as this invited significant attention from the conservative press in America, especially the John Birch Society.
JBS was not the only source to compare Wounded Knee to the Cold War in this way. The Altoona Mirror focused on the AK-47’s presence in a statement titled ‘Soviet Guns at Wounded Knee’ as evidence of communist assistance.[121] The Rapid City Journal compared Wounded Knee to the Palestinian Black September Organization’s attack on the Saudi embassy at Khartoum[122] and called for a need to fight what it termed America’s private Vietnam[123] as a new front in the global Cold War.
However, JBS’ perspective is more important for two reasons. First, JBS already had some form of influence in the tribal government, as shown by Wilson’s use of their movie at his impeachment hearings. Secondly, JBS existed as one of the largest conservative forces in America; even if it had passed the peak of its membership in 1966,[124] it still remained a significant political force, making its perspective important to understand how American conservatism engaged with the uprising. JBS appraised Wounded Knee in their publication ‘Renegades’ within the context of the Third World and the Cold War. Echoing the rhetoric of the Wilson regime, JBS argued that the Oglala had come under attack by AIM.[125] As previously noted, visual imagery was used at Wounded Knee to signal alignment and membership with the Third World through utilizing their AK-47 in photoshoots. For the JBS, this was a significant aspect of the occupation. So significant, the front page of ‘Renegades’ was a drawing of this photo. The JBS put special emphasis on the AK-47 and implied it showed the USSR was funding Wounded Knee as part of the aid they gave to ‘their revolutionaries world-wide…’[126] driving them to consider AIM as Moscow’s fellow revolutionaries.[127] Furthermore, predicting the arguments of the 1976 Congressional report, JBS would also frame the presence of Iona Andronov at Pine Ridge as evidence of a Soviet conspiracy on the reservation.[128] Finally, citing AIM’s supposed hostility to Christian institutions in Wounded Knee, JBS billed the uprising as the latest iteration in a trend of anti-clerical violence that started with the Bolshevik revolution.[129] JBS therefore repeatedly appraised Wounded Knee as a new front in the Cold War, commanded by international communism.
Overall, the perspective of JBS and other conservative outlets in America illustrates how the national critics of Wounded Knee, similar to tribal governments, presented the uprising as a new front in the Cold War, connected to both the Soviet Union and Third-World radicals, thereby connecting Wounded Knee to the Third-World revolutions of the Long ‘68.
Jakarta is coming: The ‘White’ Terror at Wounded Knee
As Wounded Knee came to a close, a (figurative and literal) white terror broke out on the reservation. And this was to be expected. If Wounded Knee was indeed a social revolution and war of national liberation against settler colonialism, a counter-revolution was to be expected. And this was precisely what occurred. The reservation was consumed in the fire of a white terror, backed by the FBI, while the settler population of South Dakota lurched to the right and transformed South Dakota into a bed of reaction triggered by this popular uprising against colonialism.
To combat the Long ’68, America cultivated a network of international anti-communist forces and state-backed paramilitaries for counter-revolution, appearing in Latin America, Indochina, and Southern Africa.[130] Post-Wounded Knee, Pine Ridge informally joined this network through a GOON-led white terror. Analyzing these events connects Wounded Knee to the Long ’68 and the Third World, as repression on the reservation acted as a counter-revolution that paralleled violence against Third-World radicals.
The counter-revolution against Wounded Knee originated from the GOONS, many of its members coming from the mixed population who joined for fear of traditionalist-led revolution, which they knew would eliminate Wilson’s patronage networks on which they depended for payment.[131] Through the GOONS, the strategy of ‘Vietnamisation’ was brought home. Indigenous policemen across America were brought to Wounded Knee to free federal forces from direct involvement.[132] The repression at Wounded Knee also had a racial element, as Wilson invited local white ranchers to join the GOONs.[133]
Support for the GOONs caused a white terror that lasted until 1976 in a federal-backed campaign ‘to exterminate AIM’.[134] At least 69 AIM members/supporters were killed, and 350 others were seriously injured in what the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights termed a ‘reign of terror.’[135] Pine Ridge’s murder rate of 170 per 100,000 people approached Chile’s murder rate under the Pinochet dictatorship.[136] It was indeed just as violent; civilians were killed by sniper fire, houses were shot up or set on fire. Per Churchill, GOONs were often identified by witnesses as culprits but were rarely tried, as they acted under a blank cheque, identical to how counter-revolutionary death squads were utilized in Latin America.[137] Similar to these paramilitaries, the GOONs also received support from the CIA, specifically its domestic branch, the ‘Special Operations Group.’[138] The terror led to so much violence that the BIA began to assume all reported deaths from Pine Ridge were homicides, while violence against AIM went uninvestigated.[139] This repression was eventually termed a small-scale civil war, with 18 deaths and 67 attacks on people and property in the first half of 1975 alone.[140]
Regrettably, for some, the scale of death here might be ‘too small’ to count as a civil war or a notable incident. What is 70 dead to the millions killed in Indonesia? The scale of killing is obviously quite different. But the rate of killing, as previous scholars have emphasized, was quite similar to that of various despots in the Third World. Furthermore, consider the civil war in Kansas during “Bleeding Kansas”, which saw the deaths of 56 people from 1854 to 1859. A rate of 11 people per year. Wounded Knee, in contrast, is more around 23 people every year. So more than twice as intense (without even accounting for population differences, of course) as Bleeding Kansas. If one can be called a civil war, so can the latter.
The testimony of Duane Brewer, second in command of Pine Ridge’s BIA police, reflected the extent of federal culpability in the killings. In the 1990s, Brewer confessed that the FBI provided extensive military support to the GOONs to repress AIM, giving M16s, grenades, plastic explosives, and machine guns.[141] The FBI’s strategy paralleled the usage of what Churchill terms local pseudo-gangs to repress revolutionaries by America in Uruguay, Guatemala, or Indochina.[142] Parallels also emerged with Vietnam’s Operation Phoenix, which saw the murder of Viet-Cong sympathizers by South-Vietnamese forces with extensive American support to root out insurgency.[143] Phoenix itself followed the international trend of repression throughout the Third World modeled on what Bevins terms the ‘Jakarta Method’ based on the anti-communist killings in Indonesia in 1966. Per Bevins, ‘Jakarta’ began to mean ‘state organised extermination of civilians who opposed… capitalist authoritarian regimes loyal to [America].’[144] While no federal authority directly invoked ‘Jakarta’ at Pine Ridge, the methodology of arming local reactionary forces to murder revolutionaries necessarily connects Pine Ridge to this anti-communist international.
The victims of terror were not ignorant of these patterns. AIM’s rhetorical response to the terror placed it into the Cold War’s context. Means, who gave an estimate of 250 murders post-Wounded Knee,[145] compared Wilson to the US-backed dictatorships of Haiti’s Duvalier and Nicaragua’s Somoza.[146] A group called ‘Native People’s Court’ as late as 1978 issued a ransom for Dick Wilson, accusing him of complicity in genocide and collaboration with America.[147] Another pro-AIM publication compared Pine Ridge to Operation Phoenix, calling Wilson a US-backed fascist, and arguing the situation was similar enough to the South Vietnamese experience that they wrote ‘if you can understand Vietnam, you can understand Pine Ridge.’[148]
Thus, in both reality and in the conception of its victims, the terror that followed the occupation was connected to the trends of counter-revolution in the Third World. Just as Wounded Knee was part of the Third-World’s revolutions, the federal response was to treat it as such by bringing ‘Jakarta’ home.
The scale of reaction spread to South Dakota as well. For example, as Catherine Stock argues in ‘Nuclear Country’ the fact that a revolution was able to break out in South Dakota had multiple significant effects for the settler population. AIM’s militancy in the area had created paranoia and drove the rapid militarisation of South Dakota’s society. Militias formed to “keep guard against Indians.” Discontent boiled over into a reaction against the clergy. As Vinen notes in ‘The Long ‘68’, the churches of America were an important supporter of civil rights and the ‘68 moment in America. Look at any transcript of newspapers from ‘73, and you will quickly find statements by clergymen and church ministers saying that they supported the struggle of the indigenous population against the cruelties of the white man. But this attitude was not popular in South Dakota. Stock points out that Wounded Knee caused an outcry among the white population of South Dakota, who complained that the major churches spent more time caring about political issues than they did their own congregation. It was this attitude that sparked a shift in South Dakota away from mainline Protestantism towards independent evangelical congregations.[149]
Certainly, the white population of South Dakota always had a notable settler identity. Many South Dakotan whites were quite racist against the indigenous population and understood South Dakota as having ‘an Indian problem’. Indeed, George Wallace got his largest pool of support in South Dakota from the population that lived next to the reservations. The Republican Party’s “Southern Strategy” was thus extended to the Dakotas after Wounded Knee. Though the Black population there was quite small, the politics of race could easily be transplanted to the fears the locals had of the indigenous population. Who was responsible for the uprising was even called into question. Anyone from the USSR, to the Black population, to even Jews was on the table.
The far-right wave that crashed over South Dakota, a reactionary and counter-revolutionary impulse to the revolution at Wounded Knee, certainly drew much of its legitimacy from the occupation. Bill Janklow, future governor of South Dakota and Attorney General of the state, said, “The only way to deal with the Indian problem in South Dakota is to put a gun to the AIM leaders’ heads and pull the trigger” and he, alongside some South Dakotans, seriously worried a genuine race war could erupt across the state. New carceral regimes also emerged in this context, as Janklow expanded the prison system of the state, with the number of those incarcerated in South Dakota (many of them native) rose by 500% since 1977.[150] The ‘trauma’ (if it can be called that) of Wounded Knee for the state’s settler population extended into the digital age, with some gun forum users in South Dakota holding it a matter of consensus that “their guns were needed for protection from Indians and the maintenance of white power.”
This settler regime has continued this paranoia against indigenous activism to the current day. And to do so it has taken up the principles of imperial internationalism; in response to the Anti-DAPL protests of the mid-2010s, some security figures proposed “that they employ the same “brilliant” counterinsurgency tactics that the Israelis use against Palestinians.”[151] To quote one last time from Stock, ‘the Occupation of Wounded Knee exemplified what Kathleen Belew calls Americans’ desire to “bring the [Vietnam] war home” in the form of the violent white power movement and its better behaved associate, the New Right. The Occupation of Wounded Knee, in short, showed that the Cold War had come home.’[152]
Wounded Knee in the Global Radical Eye
To argue that Wounded Knee was part of the Third-World revolutions of the Long ’68, it is necessary to consider global framings of Wounded Knee. Third-World perspectives matter because they highlight recognition of Wounded Knee as part of the broader Third-World liberation struggles of the time. On the other hand, First-World radicals also took part in the Long ‘68’s Third-World–aligned protests, making their interpretations important as well. These two framings differed, as the Third World saw Wounded Knee as an extension of national liberation, whereas First World radicals were somewhat divided. Most viewed it as part of the Third World movement for national liberation, while others followed a ‘legalist school’ approach and considered it an act of protest instead.
In the Third World
One account of Third World perspectives on Wounded Knee comes from the Tricontinental magazine. Tricontinental was a journal which acted as the ‘official voice’ of OSPAAL, a sub-group of the Third-Worldist Non-Aligned Movement,[153] making Tricontinental an extremely important window into the perspective of the Third World.
Tricontinental’s 85th issue was dedicated to Wounded Knee, featured on its cover through a drawing of a Lakota chief (see below). The chapter on Wounded Knee titled ‘Two, Three, Many Wounded Knees’[154] is a reference to Che Guevara’s speech to the Tricontinental, where he argued that for imperialism to be defeated, progressives had to support guerillas around the world such that there could emerge ‘two, three, ...many Vietnams.’[155] In modifying this quote, Tricontinental implicitly tied Wounded Knee to Vietnam, and more broadly as an example of Guevara’s vision of global anti-imperialist revolution. This comparison was also extended to the American government, noting America had armed its soldiers with ‘Vietnam type weaponry.’[156] Wounded Knee was seen as the same type of struggle as Vietnam, and the federal response was framed as comparable too. Tricontinental also linked Wounded Knee to Third-World radicalism more broadly. They explicitly identified the ‘Indian struggle’ as a ‘struggle for national liberation.’[157] It further described Wounded Knee as a sovereign nation at war with America.[158] This reflects both a recognition of the ION and, at minimum, a recognition of Pine Ridge being under foreign occupation. The journal argued the ION could take its grievances to the UN now that ‘the balance of powers in [the UN]’ had shifted to allow such cases to be heard.[159] A proposal for Wounded Knee was compared to the ‘colonial case of Puerto Rico and Panama’ at the UN,[160] further uniting Wounded Knee with anti-colonialism in the Third World. Tricontinental finished with one last comparison to Vietnam, quoting an AIM guerrilla who stated they had learned from the Vietnamese and were ready to fight for their independence just as the Vietnamese did.[161]
Overall, Tricontinental, acting as the Third-World’s voice, united Wounded Knee with the Third World, considering it a part of the national-liberation wars of the Long ’68, and recognizing the colonial reality of the reservations. From the Third-Worldist perspective, Wounded Knee was not seen as a civil-rights movement, and in joining the revolutions of the Long ’68, extended the logic of national liberation into a view of America as a settler-state.
The First World
In contrast to the Third World, perceptions of Wounded Knee among First-World radicals were varied. A majority agreed with the perspective of Tricontinental; however, others reduced Wounded Knee to the domain of protest.
Within the U.S., Black radicals like Kwame Ture began to ‘[think] of the Indians as equivalent to [the Vietnamese]’ recognizing Wounded Knee as the re-opening volley of a war of national liberation.[162] By invoking Pine Ridge as a land base that AIM was fighting to free,[163] Ture connected Wounded Knee to the language of Third-World struggle. This was echoed by the radical underground newspaper ‘The Berkeley Barb’ which compared AIM to the Palestinian Black Septemberists, the IRA, Black Panthers, and the Viet-Cong.[164] The Black Panther Party’s periodical also connected the uprising to the Third World, considering it ‘a victory for all poor and oppressed people throughout the world…’[165] Finally, Chicano radicals in the Maoist Venceremos organization compared the ION to the Vietnamese National Liberation Front, emphasizing the ION’s goal of independence from America.[166] A range of important radicals within America’s ’68 thereby evaluated Wounded Knee as an example of Third World national liberation at home.
This sentiment was partly echoed in Europe. Italian radicals, for example, tended to frame Wounded Knee as an extension of the Third World. Though the Italian Communist Party did not analyze Wounded Knee one way or the other, the communist newspaper il manifesto emphasized AIM’s mission to seek UN recognition[167] and argued that Wounded Knee was the same type of struggle led by Palestinian, Basque, Northern-Irish, Sahrawi, and Kurdish guerrillas,[168] connecting Wounded Knee to a wide range of Third-World militancy. Meanwhile, Angelo Quattrocchi (a key figure of the Italian ’68)[169] also wrote on Wounded Knee and claimed to have been at the uprising.[170] Quattrocchi compared Wounded Knee’s participants to the Maoist guerrillas of the Third World[171] ultimately engaged in a struggle against colonialism. Finally, the Italian periodical Fuoco! examined Wounded Knee in an anti-colonial light. The cover (see below) depicts an indigenous soldier charging an American fort.[172] It explains that the Sioux are fighting for freedom from ‘the AmeriKKKan monster.’[173] The depiction of a soldier, invoking the imagery of war, combined with the wording of a ‘fight for freedom’ reflects an understanding of Wounded Knee as a war against colonialism. Thus, throughout the Italian radical press, Wounded Knee was generally connected to the Third World.
Interestingly, British radicals generally followed the legalist school on this matter. The Marxist-Leninist newspaper ‘Morning Star’ judged Wounded Knee in its first report to be the latest in a series of protests over discrimination and housing complaints.[174] It is unlikely this misinterpretation came from the immediacy of the events, as another report on 12 March called Wounded Knee a demonstration to ‘draw attention’ to their plight.[175] Interestingly, even when reporting the ION’s declaration of independence, Morning Star insisted the occupation was a ‘dramatisation’ of ‘the plight of the Indians on the reservations.’[176] Even when reporting AIM’s mission to the UN[177] it was only considered to be a protest.[178] No connections were made between it and the broader Third World.
Meanwhile, the British Trotskyist paper ‘Socialist Worker’ followed a similar path. Though noting the historical context of colonialism and genocide at Wounded Knee, it pictured its demands as moderate calls for reforming the reservation, and made no mention of their push for self-determination, nor any connections to the Third World.[179] Wounded Knee was placed again into the realm of protest and civil rights.
The anarchists were not free of this sin either. The British eco-anarchist magazine Do or Die (DoD) also took a similar position on Wounded Knee. In an interview with indigenous activist Rob Coronado, DoD clashed with his perspective. While Coronado had previously described Wounded Knee as a response to colonialism[180] and the Nazi-like expansion of America,[181] DoD presented it not as an anti-colonial uprising, but instead through the language of reform and civil rights, termed it a ‘peaceful protest.’[182]
Why was this? One could argue that in America, Chicanos and Black radicals would not make such mistakes due to their experience of race in America, while White radicals had the memory of Vietnam to connect to Wounded Knee. Yet this cannot explain how Italian radicals, who saw no great anti-colonial war in the Cold War era, could fall so strongly on the side of seeing Wounded Knee as a force of Third-World liberation. Indeed, Britain itself was on the site of one such Third-World-aligned insurgency in the Troubles. I recall in one episode in my research at the British Library, I had found on one page of Morning Star the news of a new IRA bombing in London, and the next a pithy discussion of Wounded Knee. So why was this mistake made so consistently over the years in Britain, but not among radicals elsewhere? The question is open, and I invite anyone who is interested to ponder or investigate.
Overall, the Third Worldism of Wounded Knee was ignored by British radicals, meaning that perceptions of Wounded Knee among First-World radicals were not homogeneous. Nevertheless, British perceptions exist as outliers when compared to other major First-World radicals. For most, Wounded Knee was considered part of the Third-World’s Long ’68.
Conclusion
Without question, Wounded Knee was part of the Third-World uprisings of the Long ’68. The Oglala were driven to revolt in what they saw as a national-liberation struggle, identifying primarily with the Vietnamese. They re-interpreted the historical treaty of Fort Laramie in the language of Third-Worldism and national-liberation, while paralleling Third-Worldist diplomacy at the UN, to gain a voice on the world stage. Meanwhile, the enemies of Wounded Knee unanimously saw the rebellion in this light. Reservation authorities, federal forces, and the conservative press repeatedly used the language of the Cold War to deride AIM/OSCRO as a communist front connected to the Third World and the USSR, and decades later, even the GWOT. This attitude transcended rhetoric as tactics of repression against Third-World radicals came home, de facto placing Pine Ridge’s government into an anti-communist international of repression. Finally, international Third-Worldists identified Wounded Knee as part of their movement, and though some ‘68ers in the First World fell into the ‘legalist school,’ the majority appraised it as Third-Worldist revolution.
It would be improper, however, to discuss the connection of Wounded Knee to the international revolutions of the Third World without addressing a key concept in indigenous political philosophy, that of the Fourth World. Scholars like George Manuel have coined the term ‘Fourth World’ to describe indigenous communities around the world, typified by being stateless indigenous, impoverished, minority communities within other states. Though their politics so often mirror those of the Third World, their relationship with colonialism tends to be defined by their existence within settler-colonial nation-states. An adaptation is still possible, of course. It is simple to say that the Fourth World is a subset of the Third World; its conditions are different and more extreme, but nevertheless within the set. When understood in this way, Wounded Knee emerges as an example of what revolution and national liberation look like from within the Fourth World. Yet if Wounded Knee is an example of Fourth Worldist national liberation, the question that arises is why Wounded Knee ultimately failed to overthrow Wilson and dislodge the IRA regime from Pine Ridge? What lessons does Wounded Knee offer future revolutionaries in the Fourth World on the strategies of national liberation, what to do and what not to do, what paths to take and what mistakes to avoid?
These are not wily questions being raised for the sake of it. The Fourth World’s struggle for sovereignty continues the world over. Yes, in the U.S., the Trump administration’s militant anti-immigrant ideology has had spillovers into the reservations, but also in other areas too. In Brazil’s Amazon, where settlers still plague indigenous nations, or across Latin America where neo-colonialist regimes like Noboa in Ecuador have attacked native land rights, or in Indonesia where the state wages a counter-insurgency program in West Papua.
Again, I do not have the answers to these questions. But they are important questions to raise in continuing the debate on what liberation within the Fourth World looks like, and it would be a disservice to the revolutionaries and civilians at Wounded Knee and Pine Ridge to leave them and their experiences out of these questions.
In any case, these findings demonstrate the connections of Wounded Knee and the political/social crisis at the heart of Pine Ridge, and, more broadly speaking, the Red Power movement, and to the Third World. They further show that America must be understood through the guise of continuing settler-colonialism. Some historiographies argue the American-Indian Wars ended with the 1890 Wounded Knee massacre, as indigenous nations integrated into America and thus do not mark America today as a settler-state. Internationalizing Wounded Knee shows that most actors, domestic and international, ultimately knew this was not true. Just as national liberation was waged in the ‘settler-homelands’ of Israel or Rhodesia, Wounded Knee showed that it too could be waged in the U.S. Indigenous resistance at Pine Ridge has continued, notably in the 2016 DAPL protests, reflecting how events like DAPL signify continuing anti-colonial struggle in the reservation’s ‘Third World.’ And so, while the lists of the Third World’s great anti-colonial battles are those of Algiers or Dien Bien Phu, it must be said that Wounded Knee should be with them too.
Liked it? Take a second to support Cosmonaut on Patreon! At Cosmonaut Magazine we strive to create a culture of open debate and discussion. Please write to us at submissions@cosmonautmag.com if you have any criticism or commentary you would like to have published in our letters section.
-
Truden, J. ‘Re-examining Dick Wilson: Oglala Politics, Nation Building, and Local Conflict, 1972-1976’ South Dakota History, 48 (2018), 173-199: Dewing, R. Wounded Knee, (New York 1985): Anderson, T. “The Movement and the Sixties” (Oxford 1995), Biolsi, T. Organizing the Lakota: The Political Economy of the New Deal on the Pine Ridge and Rosebud Reservations, (Tucson 1998).
↩ -
Matthiessen, P. “In the Spirit of Crazy Horse” (New York 1991): Reinhardt, A. “Ruling Pine Ridge” (Lubbock 2009): Tóth, G. “From Wounded Knee to Checkpoint Charlie” (Albany 2016), Churchill, W. Struggle for the Land (San-Francisco 2002).
↩ -
Blansett, K. “A Journey to Freedom” (New-Haven 2018), 4.
↩ -
Churchill, W. ‘The Bloody Wake of Alcatraz. In Hoxhie, F. Mancall, P. Merrell, J. (eds.), American Nations: Encounters in Indian Country, 1850 to the Present, (New York 2001), 376.
↩ -
Ibid., 377.
↩ -
Sanchez, J. Stuckey, M. The rhetoric of American Indian activism in the 1960s and 1970s. Communication Quarterly. 48(2) (2000), 127-128.
↩ -
Vinen, R. The Long ’68 (Allen Lane 2019), xiv.
↩ -
Wallerstein, I. World Systems Analysis, (Durham 2004), 84.
↩ -
Means, R. ‘The same old song’ in Churchill, W. (ed.), Marxism and Native Americans (Boston 1992), 20.
↩ -
Prakash, G. Adelman, J. “Inventing the Third World” (London 2023), 8-18.
↩ -
Reinhardt, Ruling Pine Ridge, 20-21.
↩ -
Ibid., 24.
↩ -
Ibid., 26
↩ -
Hämäläinen, P. Lakota America, (New-Haven 2019), 17.
↩ -
Ibid., 382.
↩ -
Ibid., 384.
↩ -
Reinhardt, Ruling Pine Ridge, 28.
↩ -
Maiolo, J. Robson, L. The League of Nations, (Cambridge 2025), 1-22.
↩ -
Reinhardt, Ruling Pine Ridge, 118-126.
↩ -
Brand, J. The Life and Death of Anna Mae Aquash. (Toronto 1993), 33.
↩ -
Reinhardt, Ruling Pine Ridge, xvii-xix.
↩ -
Brand, Anna Mae Aquash, 33.
↩ -
Sanchez. Stuckey. Rhetoric of American Indian activism, 124-125.
↩ -
Charles, W. Blood Struggle: The Rise of Modern Indian Nations, (New York 2005), 144: Hedges, C. Days of Destruction, Days of Revolt. (Toronto 2012), 16.
↩ -
Starita, J. The Dull Knives of Pine Ridge. (Lincoln 2002), 299.
↩ -
Churchill, W. “Death Squads in the US: Confessions of a government terrorist” Native America (1991), 105.
↩ -
Reinhardt. Ruling Pine Ridge, 156-157.
↩ -
Wassaja, February 1973, 4.
↩ -
Reinhardt. Ruling Pine Ridge, 44.
↩ -
Ibid., 172.
↩ -
Sanchez. Stuckey. Rhetoric of American Indian activism, 124.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 1973, (Rooseveltown 1976), 16.
↩ -
Reinhardt. Ruling Pine Ridge, 172.
↩ -
Ibid, 188: Starita. Dull Knives. 306.
↩ -
South Dakota Oral History Center Records-American Indian Research Project (SDOHCR-AIRP), Tape#918, Oral History Interview with Dick Wilson.
↩ -
Matthiessen. Crazy Horse, 64.
↩ -
Reinhardt. Ruling Pine Ridge, 185.
↩ -
Rapid City Journal, 28 February 1973, 2.
↩ -
The extent to which what they sought was indeed pre-colonial is debated. As Biolsi notes, the idea of “pre-colonial” governance often deferred to the 1868 Treaty of Fort Laramie, which was of supreme importance at Wounded Knee. Yet this treaty, though on largely indigenous terms, was nevertheless an innovation from pre-colonial indigenous politics.
↩ -
Churchill, W. Wall, J. Agents of Repression, (Boston 1988), 105.
↩ -
James Eastland. Revolutionary Activities within the United States: American Indian Movement. (Washington D.C. 1976), 7.
↩ -
Ibid., 35.
↩ -
Hitchmough, S. Mays, K. Rethinking the Red Power Movement, (New York 2024), 51.
↩ -
Randall, M. ‘Two, Three, Many Wounded Knee’s’ Tricontinental. 85 (1973). 40.
↩ -
Starita. Dull Knives, (Lincoln 2002), 308.
↩ -
Ibid, 283.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 72.
↩ -
Ibid, 99.
↩ -
Ibid., 113.
↩ -
Ibid., 128.
↩ -
Kipp, W. Viet-Cong at Wounded Knee, (Lincoln 2004), 126.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 195.
↩ -
Ibid., 197.
↩ -
Ibid., 196.
↩ -
Smith, S. Hippies, Indians, and the Fight for Red Power, (Oxford 2012), 190.
↩ -
Banks, D. Erdoes, R. Ojibwa Warrior, (Norman 2004), 163.
↩ -
Zimmerman, B. ‘Airlift to Wounded Knee’ (Chicago 1976), 233.
↩ -
Means, R. Where White Men Fear to Tread, (New York 1995) , 271.
↩ -
Ibid., 188.
↩ -
Eastland, Revolutionary Activities, 32.
↩ -
Prakash. Adelman. Inventing the Third World, 8.
↩ -
Trimbach, J. Trimbach, J. American Indian Mafia. (Denver 2009), 200.
↩ -
Kappler, C. Indian Affairs: Laws and Treaties, Vol.II, (Washington 1904), 998.
↩ -
Rapid City Journal, 1 March 1973, 2.
↩ -
SDOHCR-AIRP, Tape#902, ‘Sound recording of Lewis Bad Wound reading a statement by Russell Means and a discussion with Moses Big Crow.’
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
St. Paul Dispatch, 12 March 1973, 3.
↩ -
FBI Vault, Winchester. In 176-2401, ‘Russel Means, part 13’ (21 November 1973), 10.
↩ -
Trimbach. Trimbach. American Indian Mafia, 84.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes 1987-1988, 19(6), 12.
↩ -
The Evening Press (New York), 2 March 1973, 1.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 168.
↩ -
Trimbach. Trimbach. American Indian Mafia, 104.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 55-57.
↩ -
Ibid., 67.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Prakash. Adelman. Inventing the Third World, 17.
↩ -
Prashad, V. ‘The Darker Nations’ (New York 2007), 28
↩ -
Ibid., 11-13.
↩ -
Ibid., 102.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 64.
↩ -
United Nations Archives, New York (UN-NYC). American Indians-Wounded Knee, South Dakota, In ‘S-0271-0001-04’, Meeting between the Legal Counsel and an American Indian delegation, 4 May 1973.
↩ -
Ibid, Representatives of American Indians meet United Nations Correspondents, 22 March 1973.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid., Meeting between the Legal Counsel and an American Indian delegation, 4 May 1973.
↩ -
Ibid., Representatives of American Indians meet United Nations Correspondents, 22 March 1973.
↩ -
Turner, O. Finishing the Job. Third World Quarterly, 34(7) (2013), 1195.
↩ -
Ibid., 1198.
↩ -
UN-NYC. American Indians-Wounded Knee, South Dakota. In ‘S-0271-0001-04’, Notes for the Record, 2 March 1973.
↩ -
Rapid City Journal. 23 March 1973, 2.
↩ -
UN-NYC. American Indians-Wounded Knee, South Dakota. In ‘S-0271-0001-04’, OPI Daily Press Briefing, 8 March 1973.
↩ -
SDOHCR-AIRP, Tape#918, Oral History Interview with Dick Wilson.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Reinhardt. Ruling Pine Ridge, 93.
↩ -
Westad, O. The Global Cold War (Cambridge 2007), 119.
↩ -
Reinhardt. Ruling Pine Ridge, 178.
↩ -
National Film Preservation Foundation (https://www.filmpreservation.org/preserved-films/screening-room/anarchy-u-s-a-1966, accessed 13 April 2026), Anarchy U.S.A.
↩ -
Trimbach. American Indian Mafia, 479.
↩ -
Means. Fear to Tread, 276.
↩ -
Eastland. Revolutionary Activities, 2.
↩ -
Ibid., 3.
↩ -
Means. Fear to Tread, 399.
↩ -
Eastland. Revolutionary Activities, 21.
↩ -
Ibid., 36-37.
↩ -
Trimbach. American Indian Mafia, 56.
↩ -
Ibid., 139.
↩ -
Ibid., 472.
↩ -
Ibid., 150.
↩ -
Ibid., 473.
↩ -
Ibid., 272.
↩ -
Johansen, B. Maestas, R. Wasi’chu (New York 1979), 80.
↩ -
Trimbach. American Indian Mafia, 508.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid., 509.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Zimmerman, B. Airlift, 165.
↩ -
Eastland. Revolutionary Activities, 20.
↩ -
Hodges, M. AK-47 (Chatham 2007), 2.
↩ -
Altoona Mirror, 22 March 1973, 8.
↩ -
Rapid City Journal. 23 March 1973. Pg.4.
↩ -
Ibid., 2 April 1973, 4.
↩ -
Mulloy, D. ‘The World of the John Birch Society’ (Nashville 2014), 2.
↩ -
Huck, S. Renegades: The Second Battle of Wounded Knee (Belmont 1973), 2.
↩ -
Ibid., 7.
↩ -
Ibid., 12.
↩ -
Ibid., 3.
↩ -
Ibid., 9.
↩ -
Burke, K. ‘Revolutionaries for the Right’ (Chapel Hill 2018), 2-4.
↩ -
Matthiessen. Crazy Horse, 62.
↩ -
Akwesane Notes, Voices from Wounded Knee, 123.
↩ -
Matthiessen. Crazy Horse, 73-74.
↩ -
Johansen, B. Encyclopaedia of the American Indian Movement (Santa Barbara 2013), 218.
↩ -
Churchill. Bloody Wake of Alcatraz, 383.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid., 383-384.
↩ -
Treuer, D. ‘The Heartbeat of Wounded Knee’ (London 2020), 320.
↩ -
Brand. Anna Mae Aquash, 22-27.
↩ -
Ibid., 120.
↩ -
Churchill, W. Death Squads in the US, 105.
↩ -
Churchill. W. Agents of Repression, 196.
↩ -
Bevins, V. The Jakarta Method, (New York 2020), 161.
↩ -
Ibid, 199-200.
↩ -
Means. Fear to Tread, 367.
↩ -
Ibid., 237.
↩ -
University of California-Riverside, Rupert Costo Archive, Item-004.007.007, June 1978.
↩ -
Ibid, Item-004.003.010, 1.
↩ -
Stock, C. Nuclear Country, (Philadelphia 2020), ‘Wounded Knee 1973, and the War at Home’
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Rojas-Sotelo, M. ‘The Other Network: The Havana Biennale and the Global South’ The Global South. 5(1) (2011), 156.
↩ -
Randall. Two, Three, Many Wounded Knee’s, 25.
↩ -
Paranzino, M. ‘Two, three, many Vietnam’s’ in Parrott, R. Lawrence, M. (eds.), The Tricontinental Revolution, (Cambridge 2022), 298.
↩ -
Randall. Two, Three, Many Wounded Knee’s, 38.
↩ -
Ibid., 31.
↩ -
Ibid., 37.
↩ -
Ibid., 39-40.
↩ -
Ibid., 40.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Smith. Fight for Red Power, 191.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid., 192.
↩ -
The Black Panther, 19 May 1973, 10.
↩ -
Pamoja-Venceremos, 18 April 1873, 4.
↩ -
De Giuseppe, M. “Return to Wounded Knee” In Formigoni, G. (ed), Italy and the ‘Shock of the Global’ during the 70s (Milan 2025), 136-137.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid., 141.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Caruso, M. Native Americans in Visual Countercultures, Römisches Jahrbuch der Bibliotheca Hertziana, 46 (2023), 392.
↩ -
Ibid.
↩ -
Morning Star, 1 March 1973, 7.
↩ -
Ibid., 12 March 1973, 5.
↩ -
Ibid., 14 March 1973, 5.
↩ -
Ibid., 24 March 1973, 5.
↩ -
Ibid., 26 March 1973, 5.
↩ -
Socialist Worker, 24 March 1973, 4.
↩ -
Do or Die, May 1993, 19.
↩ -
Coronado, R. My Heroes always killed Cowboys!, Do or Die, 10, (2003), 121.
↩ -
Ibid, 122.
↩